Cybersecurity

Spy Chips in Crypto Wallets: How to Buy Security Hardware Safely

Ledger and Trezor hardware wallets sold by one reseller were found with hidden cellular implants that stole recovery phrases. What happened, and how to buy wallets, security keys and other security gear without the risk.

Read in 5 countries🇸🇬🇳🇬🇺🇸🇭🇰🇪🇸9 views
Cryptocurrency coins representing digital assets
Photo: "Ethereum Classic Wallpaper - ETC Cryptocurrency" by EthereumClassic, CC CC0 1.0, via Openverse
In this article
  1. Key takeaways
  2. What happened
  3. Ledger’s discovery
  4. Trezor’s report
  5. Why this attack is so effective
  6. How to buy security hardware safely
  7. Buy direct or from listed authorised sellers
  8. Avoid used, “open box” and discounted units
  9. Never accept a pre-written recovery phrase
  10. Keep proof of purchase
  11. Do not try to “inspect” it yourself
  12. If you bought from CryptoBilis or an unknown seller
  13. Watch for follow-up scams
  14. Next steps
  15. Sources

Hardware wallets, security keys and other small security gadgets exist for one reason: to keep secrets safe even if your computer or phone is compromised. A string of incidents over the past six weeks shows the weak point can be the supply chain instead. This guide is for anyone who owns or plans to buy a crypto hardware wallet, and for businesses buying security keys or other trusted devices for staff.

Key takeaways

  • Ledger confirmed in October that a device bought from CryptoBilis, a reseller in Southeast Asia, contained a hidden implant that read the recovery phrase from the screen and sent it out over LTE.
  • Trezor later received a report of a similar implant in a Trezor Safe 5 bought from the same reseller, and both companies stopped working with it.
  • The implants did not break the wallets’ secure chips. They simply copied what the screen showed during setup.
  • Buy security hardware only from the manufacturer or its listed authorised sellers, never set up a device with a recovery phrase someone else provides, and keep your receipt.
Cryptocurrency coins representing digital assets
Photo: “Ethereum Classic Wallpaper – ETC Cryptocurrency” by EthereumClassic, CC CC0 1.0, via Openverse

What happened

Ledger’s discovery

According to Decrypt’s reporting, Ledger disclosed on 9 October that all confirmed losses it had seen involved devices sold through CryptoBilis, and on 10 October confirmed an unauthorised implant in one affected user’s device. Ledger described a separate component inside the casing: a microcontroller that decodes the 24-word recovery phrase as it appears on screen during setup and transmits it using an eSIM over a mobile network. Ledger said the implant did not modify its secure element, operating system, transactions or signatures.

An on-chain investigator traced more than $86 million in suspected thefts, a figure Ledger said came from third parties it had not fully verified. Ledger asked resellers and distributors in Southeast Asia and Hong Kong to pause sales while it investigated.

Trezor’s report

On 28 October, Trezor received a responsible disclosure report from a customer in Indonesia who bought a Trezor Safe 5 from CryptoBilis in August through an online marketplace. The customer found an extra circuit board with a cellular module and antenna between the main board and the screen. Trezor had already removed CryptoBilis as an authorised reseller on 9 October and said it had no evidence of customer losses at the time. A weekly security roundup published on 16 November reports that Trezor has since confirmed implants in three Safe 5 wallets from the reseller and released firmware 2.13.1, which blocks the implant from capturing new phrases but cannot protect phrases already exposed.

Why this attack is so effective

A hardware wallet’s security depends on the recovery phrase staying secret. Whoever has those words can rebuild the wallet on any device and empty it. The implants did not need to defeat any cryptography. They waited for the device to display the phrase once, during normal setup, and quietly sent it away. Weeks or months later, the attacker could drain the funds without ever touching the device again.

The same principle applies to other trusted hardware. Security keys, encrypted USB drives, routers and even laptops can be modified before they reach you if they pass through an untrustworthy seller.

How to buy security hardware safely

Buy direct or from listed authorised sellers

Order from the manufacturer’s own store, or from a reseller named on the manufacturer’s official website. Both Trezor and Ledger have tightened their reseller lists since these incidents. For buyers in Nigeria and elsewhere in Africa, where official shipping can be slower or costlier, it is tempting to buy from a local social media vendor or a marketplace listing. For devices that guard money or logins, the extra wait is worth it.

Avoid used, “open box” and discounted units

A secondhand or unusually cheap security device should be treated as untrusted. You cannot know who handled it.

Never accept a pre-written recovery phrase

A genuine wallet generates a new recovery phrase on the device during setup. If a box includes a card with words already printed on it, or the device is already set up, do not use it.

Keep proof of purchase

Trezor’s advice is to check the seller name on your receipt. Replacements in this case depended on proof of where the device came from.

Do not try to “inspect” it yourself

Trezor says there is no reliable way for customers to inspect a device, that weighing it is not a dependable test, and that you should not open it. Ledger has published an inspection guide but warns that opening a device can damage it. The safest defence is a trustworthy source.

If you bought from CryptoBilis or an unknown seller

  1. If you have not set it up, do not set it up and do not enter an existing recovery phrase on it. Contact the manufacturer’s support.
  2. If you have set it up, move your funds to a new wallet with a brand-new recovery phrase, created on a device from a trusted source. Restoring the old phrase on a new device does not help, because the old phrase may already be known.
  3. Update firmware through the official app only.
  4. Report losses to your local police and contact the manufacturer before sending the device anywhere.
  5. Ask about replacements. Trezor offers eligible CryptoBilis customers a new device or voucher.

Watch for follow-up scams

Trezor warns that scammers are already using this incident in phishing emails, letters and phone calls. Neither company will ask for your recovery phrase, and Ledger says it never calls or messages users directly. Anyone who asks for your words, or sends you a “replacement” device you did not request, is a fraudster.

Next steps

Check where your current security devices came from. If any were bought from a reseller you cannot confirm on the manufacturer’s site, plan to replace them and, for wallets, move funds to a fresh recovery phrase. For your business, make “authorised sources only” a written rule for buying security keys, routers and other trusted hardware.

Sources

Featured image: Photo: “Computer Chip” by JD Hancock, CC BY 2.0, via Openverse — source

Was this article helpful?

Embed this on your website

Run a website, school, church or company intranet? Paste this code to show this article as a card. It stays up to date automatically.

Or show your visitors the latest scam alerts, updated automatically:

Written by

Verified expert

Cybersecurity Analyst

Federal Capital Territory (Abuja)

  • Phising
  • Fraud Prevention
  • Cybersecurity Awareness and Training
  • Cloud Security
  • IT Risk Management

Credentials: MCPN, MNCS, IAENG | System Analyst · Web Developer · CEH · CC · CDST

Got expertise to share? Write for us →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *